Basketball

Syracuse men’s basketball crumbles in second half against No. 13 St. John’s

SU men’s basketball surrenders halftime lead, loses 79-62 to St. John’s

Orange notch second straight loss after a 16-0 flipped the script at Madison Square Garden

Alternative Text
Brody Shuffler
Syracuse forward Amarri Monroe drives to the basket against St. John’s on Nov. 15, 2026, at Madison Square Garden in New York, NY.

NEW YORK — At halftime of Syracuse men’s basketball’s return to the world’s most famous arena on Sunday, Madison Square Garden was Eden for SU fans again.

The Orange took a three-point lead into the break against an old Big East foe, and seemed on the precipice of the first marquee win under head coach Gerry McNamara. 

A crowd of 16,431, conservatively half SU fans at a designated road game, seemed to strut towards the concourse.

It wasn’t to be. Not yet, anyway.

Ultimately, No. 13 St. John’s (4-0, 0-0 Big East Conference) outscored Syracuse (2-2, 0-0 Atlantic Coast Conference) by 20 after the break and rolled to a 79-62 victory in New York Sunday. The loss was the Orange’s second in a week to a power conference opponent — and the second in a week in which SU surrendered a halftime lead.

Alternative Text
Brody Shuffler
Syracuse coach Gerry McNamara argues a call during SU’s game against St. John’s on Nov. 15, 2026, at Madison Square Garden in New York, NY.

“I’ve talked about changing the trajectory of where this program can go,” McNamara said after the game. “We need to clean a lot of things up.”

But it wasn’t all bad. Not right away, anyway.

Syracuse scored first, on a dunk from big man Luke Wilson, and shortly thereafter made perhaps the play of the season in college basketball to this point.

The Orange’s freshman point guard, Ryan Moesch — who started in place of banged up forward Mark Morano — stood alone on the left wing, SU down 6-5 four minutes in. He faked a drive against Johnnies big man Ruben Prey and stepped back with a between-the-legs dribble.

Prey stumbled onto his backside. Moesch looked at him.

Then he buried a three-pointer. The SU contingent roared.

The rest of the first-half was about as closely contested as one could ask for.

As St. John’s flirted with pulling away, Syracuse seemed to have every response. The Red Storm went up 6 near the half’s midpoint, but the Orange got 6 straight points after guard Kiyan Anthony drove for a layup, then forward Amarri Monroe and guard Garwey Dual came up with steals and fast break slams.

The Johnnies went up six again a few minutes later, but Anthony — in the building his father, SU legend Carmelo Anthony, played in for years — sparked an 11-0 Syracuse run with a pair of 3-point plays.

Alternative Text
Brody Shuffler
Syracuse guard Kiyan Anthony celebrates with teammates after a basket against St. John’s on Nov. 15, 2026, at Madison Square Garden in New York, NY.

“I thought he was awesome,” McNamara said of Anthony after the game. “He’s been terrific for us. Efficient.”

The Orange scored 16 of the half’s final 23 points. To the concourse went the Orange fans, a buzz about Madison Square Garden.

The second half, from the get-go, was a different story. Syracuse, which surrendered an 11-2 run after halftime at Indiana, surrendered an 11-2 run after halftime Sunday, too. After a McNamara timeout, that St. John’s run grew to 16-0.

“Coach [Rick Pitino] told us [at halftime] we need to play as a team,” SJU forward Keyshawn Hall said. “When we move the ball and play as a team, we can score on anybody.”

In that stretch, the Johnnies seemed to score on every shot they took. Baylor transfer Tounde Yessoufou exploded for 19 points and a career-high 14 rebounds. Hall, a former NBA Summer League player, added 18. All five Red Storm players who played more than 12 minutes scored in double figures.

St. John’s opened up a double-digit lead.

Syracuse’s offense, meanwhile, faltered. SU scored two points in the first six minutes of the second half and 10 in the first 12.

“We got stagnant,” McNamara said. “Against a team of that caliber, you can’t do [that].”

“All of us, we need to do a better job of taking care of the ball,” Orange guard Garwey Dual said. “Just making better decisions.”

Amarri Monroe, SU’s Quinnipiac transfer forward, halted the St. John’s barrage with a stretch of five straight points, but Syracuse never pulled any closer than six points. By the end, it was a win as comfortable as any St. John’s has had this year. The buzz in Madison Square Garden came from the fans in red.

The Orange turned the ball over 21 times as a team — nine of those committed by Moesch, who shot 1-7 on three-point attempts. Siena transfer Gavin Doty, SU’s leading scorer in three of its first five games, including exhibitions, went 1-8 from the field for two points.

“Pretty bad, honestly” Moesch said postgame. “I haven’t shot well. Nine turnovers is crazy.”

Alternative Text
Brody Shuffler
Syracuse guard Ryan Moesch walks off the court after a tough miss against St. John’s on Nov. 15, 2026, at Madison Square Garden in New York, NY.

“They’re tough,” McNamara added. “They’re physical defensively. They make you work. 21 turnovers against anybody isn’t going to do it.”

After satisfactory wins over New Haven and Central Connecticut, Syracuse has dropped its first true tests of McNamara’s tenure. Now, the Orange begin another stretch of mid-major opponents against Cornell at 8 p.m. Wednesday. Their next power conference foe is Oklahoma on Dec. 1.

Until then, Syracuse marches on. And its breakthrough under its new head coach remains on the table.

“Is it going to be easy? No,” McNamara said. “We’re not just going to out-talent people.

“But I believe in the group we have in the locker room.”