Movies

Clayface Review: The DCU’s brand takes on a new look

‘Clayface’ Review: The DCU’s Brand Takes on a New Look

A risky move from DC Studios pays off.

DC Studios
“Clayface” stars Tom Rhys Harries in the title role of the cult favorite villain in the DC Studios horror thriller.

Being a lifelong fan of comic books and their film and TV adaptations, I will watch nearly every project that Marvel and DC release. From my perspective, it is tough to understand what a casual viewer might think about these sprawling cinematic universes: contradicting timelines, actor recasts and superhero fatigue can turn audiences away from purchasing a ticket and getting invested into the larger story. To remedy this, DC Studios made Clayface (2026), an R-rated body horror film released just in time for Halloween. 

The movie tells the origin story of a B-tier Batman villain before Batman has even been established in the new DCU continuity pioneered by James Gunn. While that doesn’t sound like a logical choice, I commend the willingness to branch out and try new things instead of copying Marvel’s structure beat for beat.

While this is an admirable direction to take, this particular genre of movie does not appeal to a very wide audience. A gruesome body horror movie as the third installment in a new cinematic universe is not exactly welcoming to new fans. In fact, it’s not even obvious that this film is included in the DCU at all. 

However, I loved the creativity of this venture. I appreciate how DC took a chance on a good script and a small-time actor to make a great piece of horror cinema. This movie can firmly stand alone in the DC film collection and I believe that’s a good thing. The longer a cinematic universe goes on, the more tangled it gets and people will lose interest. This is the kind of film that keeps the superhero genre fresh and shocking.

Ignoring the grander implications for the DCU, I greatly enjoyed this film. You can’t go wrong with a thrilling, brutal and cathartic story about a man seeking revenge on those who took everything from him.

On a medium-sized budget of $40 million, the funds allocated towards practical effects and makeup were done exceptionally well. There were some scenes where I was taken aback by how cool and “natural” the prosthetics and effects looked.

After he completes the cutting edge cosmetic treatment, the protagonist goes to a red carpet premiere to show off his restored face. As tension builds and his emotions become erratic, his face begins eerily sliding off. The reveal is a great shot, showering his drooping face in bright neon lights from a nearby sign. From that point on, the prosthetics and special effects get even crazier and shocking. The clever editing and suspense-building elevated the movie to a different level. This is not your average comic book movie. 

Leading man Tom Rhys Harries anchors the movie. The relatively unknown British actor brings strong energy and an unsettling presence to the role. He made me empathize with his character’s arc. It gets to the point where the viewer might root for him to commit the crimes in order to exact his revenge. Casting a small actor is a smart move, mainly to keep the budget low, but also to let his talent energize the movie instead of his stardom. 

Unfortunately, now that Paramount Skydance has purchased Warner Bros. and all of its subsidiaries, the DCU is under new management. James Gunn has been ousted and replaced with Jeremy Latcham, who promises to make more family-friendly films with more popular DC characters.

While not confirmed, I think there is an extremely small chance that we seeHarries return to the role, or that we will see Clayface in future live action films for a long time. Even more unfortunate is that this will probably be the end of DC taking mid-budget big swings. 

Regardless of the future of the DCU, it had a noble beginning. They released films and series with mature themes, talented casts and good lessons, all of which are essential to making interesting and fulfilling projects that aren’t simply cashgrabs. I hope that other filmmakers can find inspiration in Clayface and defy expectations and standards in order to make something meaningful and good.

I 100% recommend seeing the film in a theater with a big crowd, but it seems like no matter how much money the movie makes, the leadership changes are final. Clayface will live on to be a reminder of artist creativity, fearlessness and tenacity in the face of adversity—both in the film and in everyday life.